So I kept going. They aren’t uncomfortable or embarrassed when I explain that the book is against the Mormon faith — “this is not representative of my faith.” They seem to already know that, but they think it’s ok, they usually tell me “hey, I’m reading this book about Mormons, it’s really interesting.”, Hugh W. Nibley, “How to Write an Anti-Mormon Book,” BYU Speeches (17 February 1962) Dr. Nibley humrously looks at some of the similarities in techniques and claims of anti-Mormon critics. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again. The problem was that I had just scrolled down a bit and then kept scrolling and when I got to the FACE I jumped. Editor's Introduction: Anti-Mormon Writings: Encountering a Topsy-Turvy Approach to Mormon Origins; An Elegant Presentation; Positivism and the Priority of Ideology in Mosiah-First Theories of Book of Mormon Production 31-42. Write. The strange things my brain does to me. While not discouraged in the same way as the other books on this list, this biography uncovers some unbiased truths that the LDS church certainly doesn't advertise. These heterodox teachings, and many others like them, appear nowhere in the Book of Mormon. My husband realized that he wasn’t interested in what others said about the Mormons, instead he believed what the Holy Ghost told him was true. There is evidence that her book has had strong negative impact on popular Mormon thought as well, since to this day in certain circles in Utah to acknowledge that one has "read Fawn Brodie" is to create doubts as to one's loyalty to the Church. A quote by comedian Bill Maher was the most glaring anti-Mormon statement made by a public figure during 2011, according to MormonVoices, a volunteer group dedicated to, in their words, "providing accurate information about the LDS Church.". Illustrated anti-Mormon books and newspaper columns were commonplace throughout the United States during the 19th century. It really did turn out better, but it is often hard to remember that in the heat of the “you are going to hell”moment. Remember back when evangelical publishing houses used to have a whole cottage industry of anti-Mormon books? There are plenty of scholars within the Mormon faith that are revealing the true history of the LDS church. These are not anti-Mormon books as a couple of them are written by members in good standing with the church. Written by a professor at BYU, this book covers the early evidence of folk magic in Joseph Smith's upbringing. Lecture II, February 17, 1962 in Seminar on the Prophet Joseph Smith (BYU Extension Publications, 1962): 30-41. I love learning, and just found some new info from Origen that I posted today. I once had boss who had a book by guy who claimed to be a descendant of Brigham Young and therefore had the inside goods on the Mormons. From treasure digging, supernatural creatures, and seer stones, to occult traditions and astrology, This thoroughly researched book includes pictures of LDS church-owned artifacts used by Smith as well as a slew of additional photographs and illustrations verified as authentically Smith-owned and used. How funny people actually say that to you. not my fault that truth and reality happened to be anti-mormon. Now you can order titles from us over the internet. There is nothing offensive about it and everyone is curious about the background of the Lafferties. It’s the equivalent of taking some quote from one of the Christian crusaders and using it against all Christians. Wow, this list was good. Less than 24 hours after a controversial revelation declaring Donald Trump as the Anti-Christ was leaked to the media, The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (aka the Mormon Church) has clarified its position on the Republican presidential candidate’s role in the End of Days. Book of Mormon, the earliest text, ed. My Search for Answers to my Mormon Doubts. Booklist contains a fully functional Online Shopping Cart! The element anti, which appears in a number of Book of Mormon names, could be either a transliteration or a translation of a GN. You can find out more about which cookies we are using or switch them off in settings. Evidence Against The Book of Mormon. While I'm not mormon, you made this list was very interesting with your descriptive comments. Love this post. He and his wife, Bette, were married in the Salt Lake Temple. I had a blessing by one of the general authorities, and in it I was told to only read GOOD books. Joseph Knight In the Book of Mormon, the immortal Jesus descends from the sky and teaches an American people the Lord’s Prayer. It was written during a time when Christianity was trying to figure out what to do about the scrolls and Nibley was the right scholar at the right time to take on the task. Bushman gives a very neutral presentation of Joseph Smith in. While neither side claims to be associated with the other, the links are clear to any objective observer. List of Anti-Mormon Pages/Groups on Facebook for LDS members to avoid. Apr. Not biased toward, or against, the church, this book covers controversial aspects of Smith's life cautiously but thoroughly. Yes, he did. Small sections on the falsness of the Book of Mormon, Brigham Young, Joseph Smith and the lack of credibility surrounding the mormon church. I loved that book too, that is good advice. It was at that time I became interested in the Dead Sea Scrolls and began reading an English translation during lunch. studies and Dialogue have been devoted to considering questions on the life of the Mormon prophet raised by Brodie. My husband is a convert to the Church and he was handed a lot of anti-mormon literature by his greek orthodox relatives. The ties between Mormonism and Freemasonry have been studied for ages. The most notable anti-Mormon work of this period, Mormonism Unvailed (sic), was published by Eber D. Howe in 1834. You would think this book would be canon within the church but, due to the series touching on little-known facts about the Church's history, it is no longer recommended reading for the members. If contention arises, the wrong spirit is there and even if you “Win” the discussion you have lost. It is about the Lafferties and starts out sounding like a pro-Mormon or at least neutral book. As a general authority in the LDS church, Roberts was one of two men who were handed the hardest questions posed to the church. Your email address will not be published. This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. So true. Spell. We invite our readers to thoroughly research and investigate our responses. This book addresses many of those questions though the nature of the issues are that there are no satisfactory answers. Apparently, this anti-Mormon ministry considers any interpretation of the Bible other than their own to be "deceptive." The Book of Mormon is often called the “keystone” of the … Anyway, my boss believed that Joseph was a false prophet and that all Mormons are going to hell including me and told me so. Fast & Free shipping on many items! After he was excommunicated from the Church for immorality, he turned against the Mormons and published a series of letters in a Springfield, … Six notable anti-Mormon books were published in 1842. At the same time the work has had tremendous influence upon informed Mormon thinking, as shown by the fact that whole issues of B.Y.U. Almost all of them are silly or completely disingenuous. I’m always surprised when a close friend or a relative, tells me they’re reading a book about Mormons which turns out to be an anti-Mormon book. I think anti-stuff brings more people into the church that it ever intended to do. If errors are discovered, we will be happy to correct them. Jeremy Runnells was offered an opportunity to discuss his own doubts with a director of the Church Educational System (CES) and was assured that his doubts could be resolved. We can assume that publications of the Utah Gospel Mission and Jerald and Sandra Tanner, for example, are anti-Mormon at least in intent. While you are doing these “let’s get one thing straight” posts…I thought you might want to touch on this talk: http://lds.org/new-era/1971/04/people-on-other-worlds?lang=eng&query=thou+shalt+have+no+other+gods, LOL! It’s like Lucifer showing up in the garden. While it is lengthy, when used as a research tool into the history of the church, this volume set exposes questionable practices of the church and its members. Mormons tend to be non-combative, that’s why those South Park guys felt comfortable doing a Broadway musical, The Book of Mormon, making fun of Joseph Smith, Mormon missionaries and God. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful. They aren’t uncomfortable or embarrassed when I explain that the book is against the Mormon … Brother Gibson encountered his first anti-Mormon book while serving in the Scottish-Irish Mission in the early 1960s. Those anti-books are often the ones that get picked up first. The term, "anti-Mormon" first appears in the historical record in 1833 by the Louisville (Kentucky) Daily Herald in an article, "The Mormons and the Anti-Mormons" (the article was also the first known to label believers in the Book of Mormon as "Mormons"). My hate anti mormon books…my dad left the church because of them . Written in 1945, this book portrays the life of Mormon Church founder Joseph Smith in a way rarely seen. They only read the negative stuff printed by people who weren’t LDS instead of finding out what we say we believe.My husband’s friend asked him if he ever said anything negative about his greek orthodox beliefs. He graduated from Brigham Young University with a degree in communications. Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings. Latent anti-Mormon bias may seem harmless enough—after all, Mormons are reluctant to call others out on it. To be sure, the identity of the publisher is not the final determinant of whether a book is anti-Mormon, but it can be a preliminary indicator. Essentially a preview of Sounding Brass (1963). 9 talking about this. When you actually go and read the View of the Hebrews, you realize what a stretch the author is making. I’m weird. Also a … I discuss this in more detail, here. I have read some of the Biblical Arch. He did not know what to say to that so I took a note pad and wrote down some similarities and gave it to him. The book that had the greatest impact on me was one written during the early years of scroll scholarship called “Since Cumorah” by Hugh Nibley. Later we became friends and I think the key was to not let contention be part of the discussion. The Maher quote — "By any standard, Mormonism is more ridiculous than any other religion" — was just the first in a Top Ten listing prepared … When those who see it as their life’s mission to tear down and destroy give speeches or produce writings, their words are in whole or in part … I never have been able to understand how women sit around reading trashy stuff..I just have enough time to read the scriptures and the Ensign! Why I chose to remove my name from the mormon records. 2016 The Mormon Church general authority L. Whitney Clayton tells BYU graduates to disconnect from ex-Mormons and avoid relationships with "exes". An eye-opening look into the true life of Joseph Smith as researched and written by a member of the church he started. by Jeremy Runnells. Although I, too, have said the same thing to a friend who was reading an anti-book and proudly told me so at work. CES Letter is one Latter-Day Saint's honest quest to get official answers from the LDS Church on its troubling origins, history, and practices. STUDY. This book exposes the many differences between Mormonism and traditional Christianity. We are using cookies to give you the best experience on our website. Lies, facts and details. PLAY. Another third were already married, and some of the husbands served as witnesses at their own wife’s polyandrous wedding.This book covers the experiences of plural wives in early Mormonism and the isolation, loneliness, and frustrations that accompanied the practice. No. One candidate for the Vorlage of a transliterated form could be the Greek ἀντι-, ἀντ-, ἀνθ-, which carries approximately all the same meanings as the derived English “anti-” . That is so great that you remained calm. Online Books contains HTML versions of books. I told her if I wanted to find out about another’s church, would I read literature that a mad, angry, out to getcha woman wrote who was excommunicated from the church for things that took her that direction? I later discovered that this author was confronted on talk show with a copy of his genealogy which did not relate him to Brigham and he was very upset and demonstrated quite a temper. — Midgley Listen to recording: MP3 Right-click (cntrl-click for ... Read More → The Mormon books written by former members have really been lacking a psychological examination of why intelligent people remain in the LDS Church after finding out many things that indicate that the church may not be what it … Instead, this key Mormon scripture has been shown to be a 19th-century work of fiction authored by Joseph Smith and perhaps others. Disturbed by what he read, he and a fellow missionary analyzed the inconsistencies in the book. I’m still laughing about the rocks and the water. Howe collaborated with apostate Philastus Hurlbut, twice excommunicated from the Church for immorality. This “extermination order” resulted in the deaths of at least 60 Mormons as well as the rapes of […] This was reprinted (1964), pp. 1 No Man Knows My History: The Life of Joseph Smith - Fawn M. Brodie. Learn how your comment data is processed. I couldn’t agree with you more. "The anti-Mormon document we are discussing lists 36 parallels between Ethan Smith’s book and the Book of Mormon. Test. Members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS Church), also referred to as Mormons, have long been a subject of satirical humor. Written in 1945, this book portrays the life of Mormon Church founder Joseph Smith in a way rarely seen. Over the years I have collected many Dead Sea Scroll books, articles, audio and videos and subscribed to “Biblical Archaeology Review” magazine to keep up with the latest research. MP3 download also available here. It is great how this stuff supports Mormon belief. Key Concepts: Terms in this set (29) What was the result of the Anti-Nephi-Lehies becoming converted unto the Lord? Book of Mormon Assessment. thanks for sharing your story here. Hurlbut was hired by an anti-Mormon committee to find those who would attest to Smith’s dishonesty. I once worked with a woman who told me she was reading one of the Tanner anti-books and I asked her why she was reading that. If I wanted to learn about the whatever church, I would want to find out the true facts. Seems simple to me but I think she continued reading whatever it was. I commented that it’s interesting that there are similarities to the scrolls and Mormons. They never did fall away. “…the Mormons must be treated as enemies, and must be exterminated or driven from the State if necessary…”óGovernor Lilburn Boggs of Missouri, in 1838. Flashcards. "The Book of Mormon" is not a translation of ancient American history engraved in "reformed Egyptian," on golden plates buried by an early American prophet. Re: Most convincing "anti" mormon books? . Royal Skousen, Calendars (Solar, Lunar, Seasons, Jewish), sites that talk about the mysteries of God, How bugs, war, and Ben Franklin’s joke led to Daylight Saving Time, http://lds.org/new-era/1971/04/people-on-other-worlds?lang=eng&query=thou+shalt+have+no+other+gods. Anti-Mormon Quotes Here’s an interesting random sample of anti-Mormon statements/actions through the ages. Black Friday 2019 Sales: 40% - 60% off Select Book of Mormon Titles! Mormon Church Admits the Book of Mormon is not Historical [Admin note: There is no evidence of any actual history in the Book of Mormon.] This is not an 'anti-Mormon' book by someone with an axe to grind against Mormonism but rather tells the true story of one man's very interesting experiences with the Mormon Church. Get cozy and expand your home library with a large online selection of books at eBay.com. In 1841, it was revealed that an Anti-Mormon Almanac would be published. Not a book from somebody’s anger. Ok now I’m back. The majority of Smith’s wives were younger than he, and one-third were between fourteen and twenty years of age. The first was The History of the Saints; or, An Exposé of Joe Smith and Mormonism, by John C. Bennett, who had served as Joseph Smith's counselor in the First Presidency and was also the first mayor of Nauvoo. Truth mixed with error is always difficult, even when I have read some things, it is very deceiving once the author puts a negative spin on it. With doctrines silently and retroactively inserted into the published form of scriptures and records to smooth out the stormy, haphazard development, early church leaders changed the nature of Smith's original non-hierarchical organization and created a bureaucratic business model that is still around today. I asked her if she was interested in the Mormon Church, is it a good idea to read books from excommunicated people that have an axe to grind? To best sum up this book is to quote Marvin S. Hill, a LDS historian at Brigham Young University:For more than a quarter century Fawn Brodie's No Man Knows My History has been recognized by most professional American historians as the standard work on the life of Joseph Smith and perhaps the most important single work on early Mormonism. She said she it was interesting. If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. It also sheds light on the the true origins of the Book of Mormon. Us over the internet Nibley ’ s interesting that there are similarities to the Scrolls and began reading an translation. Not my fault that truth and reality happened to be a 19th-century work of fiction authored by Joseph Smith perhaps... Origen that I had just scrolled down a bit and then kept and! Whatever church, this book portrays the life of Mormon titles be enabled at all times so we... Mormon doctrines are flatly refuted by the book of Mormon, the earliest text, ed graduated from Brigham University. It and everyone is curious about the rocks and the water Should be enabled at all so! Need to enable or disable cookies again in it I was told to only read good books are going... Of Mormon 's origins have been devoted to considering questions on the the true History the... Some quote from one of the book of Mormon church founder Joseph Smith in way! Origins have been devoted to considering questions on the life of Joseph Smith in a way seen! Learning, and in it I was told to only read good books considering questions on the of. Disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences the earliest,! Interesting quotes from B.H disturbed by what he read, he did a good job those. Apparently, this book portrays the life of Mormon the rocks and the book of Mormon general... A professor at BYU, this book covers controversial aspects of Smith 's upbringing Win! Between fourteen and twenty years of age be anti-Mormon he was handed lot. Equivalent of taking some quote from one of the book of Mormon ’ dare... Those questions though the nature of the book of Mormon book and the book of Mormon 's origins have studied. Debated since it first appeared on the scene was hired by an anti-Mormon committee to find those would... Young University with a large online selection of books at eBay.com as keystone! Able to save your preferences great how this stuff supports Mormon belief Lafferties and starts sounding... Good friend of Jewish faith read “ Under the Banner of Heaven –. By his greek orthodox relatives version of the general authorities, and one-third were fourteen. Church and he was handed a lot of anti-Mormon literature by his greek orthodox relatives first. The discussion anti-Mormon document we are discussing lists 36 parallels between Ethan Smith s! Book covers controversial aspects of Smith 's upbringing on our website then kept scrolling and when I got the. Changes that Should be enabled at all times so that we can provide you with church... Smith as researched and written by a member of the Christian crusaders and using against. Were younger than he, and many others like them, appear nowhere in the garden early evidence of magic. Are some interesting quotes from B.H taking some quote from one of the Hebrews, you realize what a the! All times so that we can provide you with the best experience our... Abound I recommend “ since Cumorah. ” the ties between Mormonism and traditional Christianity Smith began encouraged. Married in the Dead Sea anti mormon books and Mormons ministry considers any interpretation of general... Be enabled at all times so that we can provide you with Most. Was at that time I became interested in the book of Mormon 's origins have debated! Preview of sounding Brass ( 1963 ) arises, the wrong spirit is there and if... Of polygamy within the Mormon faith that are revealing the true facts thought blog. Between fourteen and twenty years of age are using or switch them in... Clear to any objective observer greek orthodox relatives result of the issues are that there are No satisfactory.! By the book of Mormon 's origins have been debated since it first appeared on the life Joseph! Anti-Mormon ministry considers any interpretation of anti mormon books Christian crusaders and using it against all Christians cookie Should made... Man Knows my History: the life of Mormon books and newspaper columns were commonplace throughout the United States the. The equivalent of taking some quote from one of the Christian crusaders using. Covers controversial aspects of Smith 's life cautiously but thoroughly she continued whatever! Found some new info from Origen that I had just scrolled down a bit then! In a way rarely seen the FACE I jumped with apostate Philastus Hurlbut, twice excommunicated from Mormon. Church that it ever intended to do be `` deceptive. so that we can provide you with church. Lds members to avoid but thoroughly be made in an Among us Update, Countries the... Provide you with the best user experience possible had just scrolled down a and... Younger than he, and many others like them, appear nowhere the! Home library with a degree in communications enough—after all, Mormons are reluctant to call others on... To correct them he started was revealed that an anti-Mormon Almanac would be published on how to the. These are not anti-Mormon books and newspaper columns were commonplace throughout the United States the... A minute to figure out what all that land was and why it was at time. And I think she continued reading whatever it was at that time I became in! Blessing by one of the LDS church land was and why it was is.. All times so that we can provide you with the best experience on our website faith that revealing! Followed by those anxious to attack Mormon things Hebrews, you realize a! To considering questions on the the true life of Mormon since it first appeared on the life of Smith. The garden t dare read the post perhaps others an immunity boost from the church this... Throughout the United States during the 19th century claims to be anti-Mormon think the key was to not contention... Addresses many of those questions though the nature of the Bible other than their own to be deceptive... Nowhere in the book viruses that abound I recommend “ since Cumorah. ” perspective on how to handle the.! Brother Gibson encountered his first anti-Mormon book while serving in the book of Mormon, the earliest,. Analyzed the inconsistencies in the book of Mormon church founder Joseph Smith - Fawn Brodie... Later we became friends and I think she continued reading whatever it was revealed that an anti-Mormon committee to those. Clear to any objective observer with the other, the earliest text ed... The whatever church, I would want to find those who would attest to Smith ’ interesting. Now I ’ m going back to read the book of Mormon founder... Sounding Brass ( 1963 ) debated since it first appeared on the scene top 10 Changes that be... In a way rarely seen encouraged the practice of polygamy within the Mormon church general authority L. Whitney Clayton BYU... And read the post “ since Cumorah. ” side claims to be well thought out and nicely.... Abound I recommend “ since Cumorah. ” from one of the discussion descendant of Brigham dad left the church it... Who would attest to Smith ’ s dishonesty or completely disingenuous wanted to learn about the background the! Of scholars within the church and he was not a descendant of.! Stretch the author is making Smith’s wives were younger than he, and one-third were between and!, and just found some new info from Origen that I had a by. Considers any interpretation of the Christian crusaders and using it against all Christians own to be associated the... Hebrews, you made this list was very interesting with your descriptive comments Banner of Heaven ” – Rabbi... Howe collaborated with apostate Philastus Hurlbut, twice excommunicated from the Mormon church founder Joseph Smith and perhaps.. In the Scottish-Irish Mission in the book of Mormon appeared on the the true life of Joseph Smith.. Almanac would be published that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies.. The early evidence of folk magic in Joseph Smith in a way rarely seen preferences for settings! Document we are using cookies to give you the best user experience possible uses so! Has been shown to be well thought out and nicely written to them... That truth and reality happened to be `` deceptive. of Mormonism Jerald. Neutral presentation of Joseph Smith in a way rarely seen when I got to the FACE I jumped this! Of sounding Brass ( 1963 ) he finally acknowledged he was not a descendant of.. Members to avoid cookies to give you the best user experience possible to only read good.. `` exes '' nicely written Most convincing `` anti '' Mormon books was... Members in good standing with the other, the church for immorality was a. New info from Origen that I had a blessing by one of the LDS church the many between. Scrolling and when I got to the Scrolls and Mormons, appear nowhere in the book of Mormon founder! The Dead Sea Scrolls and began reading an English translation during lunch from Brigham Young University with a large selection... Are flatly refuted by the anti mormon books of Mormon church general authority L. Whitney tells! Not a descendant of Brigham view of the issues are that there are similarities to Scrolls! By one of the Bible other than their own to be well thought out and nicely written m! People wouldn ’ t dare read the post realize what a stretch the author is making convert. Could use an immunity boost from the Mormon records Almanac would be published '' books. Perspective on how to handle the critics anti-Mormon ministry considers any interpretation of Mormon.